Back to case studies
Agency
Madera Metro
Location
Madera, California
Engagement
Microtransit feasibility study

Comparing fixed-route and on-demand options in Madera

Modeled results at a glance

Option A: Lower cost at the same ridership

lower cost at the same ridership
28%
A separate modeled scenario focused on cost efficiency.

Option B: More riders at the same cost

more riders at the same cost
42%
Potential identified in a modeled service scenario.

Modeled potential from Ontra’s planning engagement, not observed changes in service, ridership, or spending. The figures represent alternative scenarios, not simultaneous benefits of one plan.

Travel demand and proposed service

Existing travel patterns informed a proposed design combining fixed routes with on-demand service. The design shown is a study proposal, not an implemented change.

Demand: Existing travel patterns

Madera’s existing routes and service area overlaid with trip locations, sized and colored by trips per month.
Current demand among transit users, with dots sized by monthly trip volume.

Design: Fixed routes + on-demand

Proposed Madera service with two core fixed routes and a citywide on-demand microtransit zone shaded blue.
Proposed service combining two core fixed routes with citywide on-demand coverage.

Ontra supported Madera Metro’s microtransit feasibility study with demand forecasting and service-scenario modeling, helping compare ways to improve mobility within available resources.

The challenge: choose the right mix of service

Madera Metro set out to explore how on-demand service could complement existing routes, shorten waits, and connect riders to jobs, schools, healthcare, and everyday needs. The feasibility study pairs service analysis with community input.

Flexlynqs led the project, Ontra provided its planning platform to model service scenarios and forecast demand, and Southwest Strategies Group led community outreach. A public workshop at Madera City Hall gathered residents’ perspectives on the transit system.

The approach: compare options before committing resources

Ontra’s role was to support the study with demand forecasts and alternative service scenarios. The work explored fixed-route changes and on-demand service as parts of the same planning question: how to use available resources to serve residents’ travel needs.

Comparing scenarios makes the tradeoff between ridership and cost explicit. One scenario can prioritize reaching more riders with the current budget, while another can explore delivering the same ridership at lower cost.

The results: two ways to improve resource efficiency

Ontra’s planning work modeled an option with potential for 42% more riders at the same cost, and a separate option with potential for 28% lower cost at the same ridership.

The two scenarios illustrate different priorities: serving more riders with the same resources, or maintaining ridership with a smaller budget. Community priorities and agency review remain central to choosing what to advance.

What this gives planners

The study supports a more concrete conversation about the role of microtransit alongside fixed routes. By comparing predicted demand and resource needs, the team can discuss service options with a clearer picture of the tradeoffs and a basis for phased planning.

Further reading

What service question is your agency working on?

Explore how demand modeling and optimization can help compare options for your network.

Talk to our team